Starter or Jackshaft?

[gasteward]

My 2003 FXD recently began failing to stay connected when starting. When the starter button was pushed, the starter assy would engage for a short time - then quit, with a loud 'crannkk' noise. I thought it might be the solenoid clutch, for the normal failure mode of the jackshaft is a total disconnect. I replaced the clutch with a Harley kit and cleaned the solenoid surfaces, the starter motor was healthy and turning. It continues to do the same thing.

Could it be the jackshaft - grabbing, but only partially? Has anyone dealt with this before?

Thanks in advance for any input you may have.

 

[glider]

Sounds like the starter drive itself rather than the jack shaft as you said. It's like a one way clutch that when it goes or gets weak will not keep the starter gear engaged with the ring gear on the clutch basket.

http://www.hdtimeline.com/harley_da...ues/1683-starter_spins_no_start.html#post8531

 

[gasteward]

Glider, thanks for the input. I have ordered a new starter, should be here by Wednesday. I will let you know what happens.

Tony