My 2012 Fat Bob had a similar symptom with the forward shifter, it would get stuck down when I downshifted, and get stuck up when I upshifted. My first thought was return spring in tranny broke but it was merely the shift lever shaft binding up in its bore. (I'm talking about the forward controls here, no where near the tranny). All I had to do was remove the shift lever and shaft, clean it and the bore up, grease it up good, and put it back together. Whole process took only 15 minutes or so. Maybe you'll get lucky and it will be a similar situation with the brake shaft. I figure either it never was greased because it's not part of the assembly process at the factory or if it was greased, it got washed out from rain and washing. I packed that sucker full of wheel bearing grease and it works better than new now and no shop monkey had to scratch up my bike! Yay! If it doesn't work out this way for you, I agree with Jack! he's the MAN!